We have some folks that are experts in this field on the forum and maybe they can explain the thermo-conductivity of free eleltrons in metals better than I can. Silver seems to be the best and then copper and gold and then aluminum. I believe that the figures given are for a pure substance.
http://www.interfacebus.com/Reference_heat.htmlThermal Conductivity for Different Metals
Metal [Material] Symbol, Atomic Thermal Value
Silver Ag 4.08
Copper Cu 3.94
Gold Au 2.96
Aluminum Al 2.18
Beryllium Be 2.00
Tungsten W 1.74
Rhodium Rh 1.50
Molybdenum Mo 1.46
Chromium Cr 0.937
Nickel Ni 0.92
Platinum Pt 0.716
Tin Sn 0.666
Tantalum Ta 0.575
Lead Pb 0.353
Titanium Ti 0.219
Manganese Mn 0.078
In the real world nothing is pure and we have alloys and they are a bit different when transfering heat.
http://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/therm ... d_429.htmlThermal Conductivity - k - (W/mK)
Material/Substance Temperature (oC) 25 125 225
Acetone 0.16
Acrylic 0.2
Air 0.024
Alcohol 0.17
Aluminum 250 255 250
Aluminum Oxide 30
Ammonia 0.022
Antimony 18.5
Argon 0.016
Asbestos-cement board 0.744
Asbestos-cement sheets 0.166
Asbestos-cement 2.07
Asbestos, loosely packed 0.15
Asbestos mill board 0.14
Asphalt 0.75
Balsa 0.048
Bitumen 0.17
Benzene 0.16
Beryllium 218
Brass 109
Brick dense 1.31
Brick work 0.69
Cadmium 92
Carbon 1.7
Carbon dioxide 0.0146
Cement, portland 0.29
Cement, mortar 1.73
Chalk 0.09
Chrome Nickel Steel (18% Cr, 8 % Ni) 16.3
Clay, dry to moist 0.15 - 1.8
Clay, saturated 0.6 - 2.5
Cobalt 69
Concrete, light 0.42
Concrete, stone 1.7
Constantan 22
Copper 401 400 398
Corian (ceramic filled) 1.06
Corkboard 0.043
Cork, regranulated 0.044
Cork 0.07
Cotton 0.03
Carbon Steel 54 51 47
Cotton Wool insulation 0.029
Diatomaceous earth (Sil-o-cel) 0.06
Earth, dry 1.5
Ether 0.14
Epoxy 0.35
Felt insulation 0.04
Fiberglass 0.04
Fiber insulating board 0.048
Fiber hardboard 0.2
Fireclay brick 500oC 1.4
Foam glass 0.045
Freon 12 0.073
Gasoline 0.15
Glass 1.05
Glass, Pearls, dry 0.18
Glass, Pearls, saturated 0.76
Glass, window 0.96
Glass, wool Insulation 0.04
Glycerol 0.28
Gold 310 312 310
Granite 1.7 - 4.0
Gypsum or plaster board 0.17
Hairfelt 0.05
Hardboard high density 0.15
Hardwoods (oak, maple..) 0.16
Helium 0.142
Hydrogen 0.168
Ice (0oC, 32oF) 2.18
Insulation materials 0.035 - 0.16
Iridium 147
Iron 80 68 60
Iron, wrought 59
Iron, cast 55
Kapok insulation 0.034
Kerosene 0.15
Lead Pb 35
Leather, dry 0.14
Limestone 1.26 - 1.33
Magnesia insulation (85%) 0.07
Magnesite 4.15
Magnesium 156
Marble 2.08 - 2.94
Mercury 8
Methane 0.030
Methanol 0.21
Mica 0.71
Mineral insulation materials, wool blankets .. 0.04
Molybdenum 138
Monel 26
Nickel 91
Nitrogen 0.024
Nylon 6 0.25
Oil, machine lubricating SAE 50 0.15
Olive oil 0.17
Oxygen 0.024
Paper 0.05
Paraffin Wax 0.25
Perlite, atmospheric pressure 0.031
Perlite, vacuum 0.00137
Plaster, gypsum 0.48
Plaster, metal lath 0.47
Plaster, wood lath 0.28
Plastics, foamed (insulation materials) 0.03
Plastics, solid
Platinum 70 71 72
Plywood 0.13
Polyethylene HD 0.42 - 0.51
Polypropylene 0.1 - 0.22
Polystyrene expanded 0.03
Porcelain 1.5
PTFE 0.25
PVC 0.19
Pyrex glass 1.005
Quartz mineral 3
Rock, solid 2 - 7
Rock, porous volcanic (Tuff) 0.5 - 2.5
Rock Wool insulation 0.045
Sand, dry 0.15 - 0.25
Sand, moist 0.25 - 2
Sand, saturated 2 - 4
Sandstone 1.7
Sawdust 0.08
Silica aerogel 0.02
Silicone oil 0.1
Silver 429
Snow (temp < 0oC) 0.05 - 0.25
Sodium 84
Softwoods (fir, pine ..) 0.12
Soil, with organic matter 0.15 - 2
Soil, saturated 0.6 - 4
Steel, Carbon 1% 43
Stainless Steel 16 17 19
Straw insulation 0.09
Styrofoam 0.033
Tin Sn 67
Zinc Zn 116
Urethane foam 0.021
Vermiculite 0.058
Vinyl ester 0.25
Water 0.58
Water, vapor (steam) 0.016
Wood across the grain, white pine 0.12
Wood across the grain, balsa 0.055
Wood across the grain, yellow pine 0.147
Wood, oak 0.17
Wool, felt 0.07
1 W/(m K) = 1 W/(mo C) = 0.85984 kcal/(h m oC) = 0.5779 Btu/(ft h oF)
In the automotive world other factors come into play also like price, ease of manufacture, packaging, and handling, along with some other factors like weight. So what we get now are aluminum radiators with pastic tanks. We used to get all brass and then brass tanks and tubes with copper fins.
Ever pick up a S1 or S2 radiator, about 18 pounds vs an S4 radiator at 8 pounds. I don't have an aluminum alloy radiator out of a Elan to weigh but my guess it its on pare with the S4 unit but the aluminum being around 2.5 times better with the heat transfer you are a bit better than the original S2.
Water or antifreeze do not cool these are just the transfer agents that move the heat from where you don't want it to where the mass of the radiator can give it off.
Most of this is just a bit of spew on my part as I don't know anything...
Gary