billwill wrote:Plus 2 wrote:Bill I don't subscribe to being part of a forum designed to help fellow owners that just say's 'Google this and Google that' but the direct links you have supplied here are valuable information. Individuals surely should be able to ask a simple question and find members willing to assist first hand. The 200+ google links you provided me when I asked a question on Mick Miller driveshafts did NOT provide the answers to the question I asked BTW.
Regards
Steve
This afternoon I searched hundreds of Googled links to find those choice items above; it took about 3 hours. I'm really sorry if you found that kind of effort too much hassle in the case of the Mick Miller driveshafts, but on that occasion I was just on my way out to a meeting and if I don't know an answer, but I do know how an enquirer might find that answer, then I give the latter information.
Who knows, you might have been lucky and found what you were looking for with the first few links and got your answer long before I or any other member on here could give you a detailed answer.
The subject of how I choose to help enquirers is CLOSED, I've been here a long time and have helped many many people. How I do it is my concern.
Bill,
I am certainly not criticsing your efforts but pointing out exactly what you confirm yourself.
Searching Google can be very time consuming.I commend your efforts and anyone who puts this time in and the key is actually putting up the links and not just responding with 'google the issue' or 'search the library' IMHO.
For me I need to manage my time and stick to just answering the OP's concerns built up from what I have been trained or personal knowledge from actual hands on experience over 45 years owning and working on classic cars, coming from a family that founded one, if not the largest automotive OE component company in the UK, running my own automotive OE supply company and then working in a senior position for the UK's largest luxury car manufacturer under Ford ownership where I was responsible for producing the engineering prototype test cars.
I find in my later (early retired) years the time then spent responding can be quick and working on several forums which include Ferrari, Rolls Royce, MGB and several specialised electrical circuit design sites allows me more time to write a detailed personal response.
The variation on how people respond is what makes these forums valuable and why always best for any member to simply ask the question. Even if it has been asked before I still politely respond covering any OP's concerns.
Like I said in the PM's we traded had you used the 'quote' feature making it clear as you have now expressed in your PM response to me you were actually responding to 'troonsprint's' post who brought up the alternators I would not have even sought clarification on the fact your reply followed directly after my post and I felt it was belittling my efforts in assisting the OP.
I agree all sorted now and CLOSED.
I did pick up one interesting paragraph from the holdenpaedia site and I quote directly as copied and pasted
''A check showed the Charge light wasn't coming on which meant no excitation for the Rotor.
A while back on the forum the view became that the charge light
was not necessary for a Bosch 85 amp Alternator because they can self excite. I couldn't make mine self excite no matter how high the revs.
After driving the 20kms home at night, the 6 year old 530 CCA Delco Battery didn't have enough charge left in it to push over even one piston on an attempted start.''This is simply one of my issues when searching websites in that it is easy to get contradictory information as Paul Hunt's comment on the MG website states the opposite and certainly exactly as I have posted previously self excitation must NOT be taken as a given.
Regards
Steve