Re: Gearbox swop?
Posted: Thu Oct 21, 2010 11:06 am
Hi all
Re this continuing argument about silicon fluid.
I'm no expert on these matters so it's personal experience only I'm afraid- the more informed out there will have to correct any errors but- as far as I'm aware for anything (solid or liquid) to absorb water doesn't it have to exhibit "annhydrous " qualities- this is my distant memory of chemistry lessons so a solid will have to have a lower moisture content than it's surroundings and attract water vapour (think biscuits). Where if another solid has a higher water content than its surroundings it will lose some of it (think bread).
OK a simple example and I know it involves a lot more factors than I've detailed.
In the case of "normal" brake fluid presumably its chemical composition means that it is a natural attractant for water (possibly irrespective of the surrounding water content of the atmosphere).
On the other hand (correct me) silicon fluid doesn't attract water because of its make up so why should a silicon hydraulic system "pull" in water if it's not combining with it.
I've used this stuff for over 20 odd years and have never found any "pools" of water in the systems when I've done a hose/seals change.
Car manufacturers "possibly" have a vested interest in systems that last longer than they'd like.
I also remember reading a long debate about this on an american car forum- one of the contibutors asked why the american military used silicon fluids in some of their hardware- and have done for many years if it was "suspect".
Just my thoughts.
John
Re this continuing argument about silicon fluid.
I'm no expert on these matters so it's personal experience only I'm afraid- the more informed out there will have to correct any errors but- as far as I'm aware for anything (solid or liquid) to absorb water doesn't it have to exhibit "annhydrous " qualities- this is my distant memory of chemistry lessons so a solid will have to have a lower moisture content than it's surroundings and attract water vapour (think biscuits). Where if another solid has a higher water content than its surroundings it will lose some of it (think bread).
OK a simple example and I know it involves a lot more factors than I've detailed.
In the case of "normal" brake fluid presumably its chemical composition means that it is a natural attractant for water (possibly irrespective of the surrounding water content of the atmosphere).
On the other hand (correct me) silicon fluid doesn't attract water because of its make up so why should a silicon hydraulic system "pull" in water if it's not combining with it.
I've used this stuff for over 20 odd years and have never found any "pools" of water in the systems when I've done a hose/seals change.
Car manufacturers "possibly" have a vested interest in systems that last longer than they'd like.
I also remember reading a long debate about this on an american car forum- one of the contibutors asked why the american military used silicon fluids in some of their hardware- and have done for many years if it was "suspect".
Just my thoughts.
John